A nice powerful amp should put out cleaner power and therefore put less stress on weak speakers at the same volume the old amp could muster. As long as the power isn't cranked all the way up it should be fine.
It's also possible the amp isn't really able to put out what it says it can. That seems to be especially true of newer amps.
TundraTalk.net forum offers the most comprehensive collection of Toyota Tundra information. Find discussions on the Toyota Tundra Diesel, TRD Pro, SR5, lift kits, towing capacity, classifieds, and more!