Never used blue, but you can't go wrong with black. Guess it depends what you are using it for. IMO it would look strange if it was not a color match unlike the contrast with black. For less then 5 bucks a can try it both ways and pick or peel.
TundraTalk.net forum offers the most comprehensive collection of Toyota Tundra information. Find discussions on the Toyota Tundra Diesel, TRD Pro, SR5, lift kits, towing capacity, classifieds, and more!